It seems only weight is registered. I was offered and received a refund instead. And my carpet isn’t overly thick. I assume this will get better with more data history for it to go on. With the WiFi scale, my guess is they’ll either have you up and running in a few minutes, or it’ll take a lot longer. In any event we have loved ours and we are pretty much a Garmin family so it integrates well overall. What happens then? Vectors: fiddly, expensive, pods prone to break Bei der Endbewertung zählt viele Eigenarten, damit relevantes Ergebniss zu sehen. Only recently the site and app have changed to add a time field when entering your weight. First time your review has let me down Ray. Other measurements have fluctuated marginally so it is strange that BF hasn’t fluctuated as well… it seems to be a known bug on the Garmin forum. Do not edit anything, go back and out. Not everyone has a smart phone and without a smart phone initial set just is not going to happen (I do have a smart phone but many of my patients do not). And, we know consumers are (which is really what counts). The retail package includes the four AAA batteries and feet to use the scale on a low carpet surface. I use garmin for all fitness products and would have liked to stay with them for the scale, but the lack of integration with MFP was a huge problem for me. and nowhere close to reality because it appears Garmin chose to split the difference of the normal and athlete profiles on other scales. Looking at my last few garmin buys: Same problem. I know, there are so many ways you could approach this. However, if you don’t care about advanced metrics and you use other platforms for your weight – then you can save a bunch of money and get a Withings or Fitbit scale. Advertise | The not integrating weight and the other metrics with TrainingPeaks/sportstracks/etc part is what is confusing me the most. I recently set up a wifi security camera with pan/tilt capabilities and various alerts within minutes of taking it out of the box. Is there anything within the settings I missed? I also had a problem with what appeared to be a failed automatic update which forced me into rigamarole similar to yours (though nowhere near as protracted), but I did get it working again. Thanks. On ours we’ve noticed it will not provide metrics, other than weight, for our 10 year old son. Full Circle of Wellness and Weight Management. Simple. Bathroom scales need to do one thing: consistently give you a weight measurement that you can trust. It does not appear to sync my existing weight when I connect via Garmin Express (desktop), nor via WiFi. I tested this over the weekend. They just look at chunks of text – big vs small. About this Garmin Index S2 smart scale review: I used the Garmin Index S2 for nine days. If you have an Index scale, and you want to send that data anywhere besides Garmin, I have an app called Smart Scale Sync which will let you send your weigh-ins to Strava, Fitbit, TrainerRoad, Peloton, Concept2, and Polar Flow. Day6 68,2 9,1 43,2 29,9 What’s worse, if you manually enter your weight in MFP, it overwrites your scale’s data in Garmin Connect deleting the body fat % metrics etc. You state that the ability for data syncing with 3rd parties is already in place and have noted (correctly I think) that the lack or sync is a deal breaker for many. Even when I placed a 1/4″ piece of plexi glass under it. This may or may not be the first time someone has thrown a wrench at you for pressing their buttons. Calipers are still superior when it comes to measuring body fat than this (uses BIA measurement which can lack precision). I tried to aim for a phrasing that didn’t have douchey in it however ;): “Either way – there’s really no excuse for Garmin not offering 3rd parties the weight data (nor any ability for you to export it out yourself). Stiil is not possible to Sync the weight on Garmin with TP? Her iCloud login signs her out every 24 hours right now. Garmin is pretty clear about their support commitments, and this runs afoul of that. Expand | Collapse. Garmin Index WiFi Smart Scale (select drop-down for white or black version). Then hit up Wiggle at the link below! Thank you! They already have the platform (Garmin Connect Auto Sync) setup to do exactly this. Until Garmin understands the people most people work and therefore are not available to sit on hold M-F during a working day I will always give Garmin’s help line the lowest rating. On paper, Index Scale is a very good product, offering direct connection to garmin, providing some simple efficient metrics. link to youtu.be. It works fine. The craziest part is it is the most expensive scale in the wifi space too. I guess, if the product just works you don’t have the need to write in these forums. I changed it back to activity class 7 and now I can use the scale again – please warn users that the scale is not usable or accurate if set above activity level 7. sure is not normal. Yesterday i swapped out the dead batteries and the display said 3.10 so it is getting the updates. Search Results. Next, it’ll ask you your name. There are essentially two main ways to view your data from the weight scale: From the Garmin Connect website, and from the Garmin Connect Mobile phone apps (iOS/Android/Windows Phone). These are things they can fix but I find it sloppy and disappointing. The answer was a very terse: Nope. I do add bullets from time to time in reviews that are pros/cons. Good review, but I have one question and one possible correction. Possibly a deal breaker. It helps complete the overall picture of focusing on our health and the decisions we make, or don’t make. FWIW both the Withings and Garmin Smart scale are supported by SportTracks and work perfectly. I use Garmin Connect primarily but have it connected to MyFitnessPal (secondary use). Not really unfortunately. The only things I can think of are that A) if a company that garmin intends to compete against (ie. Garmin has confirmed to me that weight data was NEVER a feature to transfer. Tried a lot of debug stuff but no luck. Eventually, I got a replacement that worked. Quick comment because the number of comments from unhappy users here gave me pause before buying. It’s annoying at @#$#. If this is just the way this device is it’s going back to the store. I am weighing Garmin Index Wifi Smart Scale versus UA scale. This in spite of the index still for sale on the Garmin au site. Terms of Use, Garmin Index S2 smart scale review: in pictures, Microsoft is going to have lots of clouds for industries. I can ride or run in the heat, or ride my trainer and sweat a ton, and the S1 will claim that my body water will increase. This will be a very short section. They chose not to enable weight sync. 2. In theory the scale should detect that the user on it doesn’t closely match one of the registered users, and display a guest icon (a little dude+question mark). Plus, you'll be more awesome. I got the response “we do not have any scales within our product range” (that was feb 13th). The Garmin Index Smart Scale wirelessly keeps track of your weight, body water, fat mass, and bone mass, but it's a bit pricey for what you get. garmin index smart scale Home; Cameras; Sports; Accessories; Contact Us All later Edge models have this feature removed. Any news on that? iPhone app, iPad, mac with garmin express. Weight 185.1 lbs Get all your awesome high quality DCR kit and gear here! Unfortunately the future has gotten a bit murky wit the Nokia acquisition. “This will be a very short section. I just got off the phone with Garmin support for the fourth time. I’ve had very high variances with this scale in the same day. Once you complete the ANT+ set-up the scales stop showing a Bluetooth connection icon and revert to the WiFi + Wrench dead end that I got to using an i-device setup. They know they have a software issue but continue to sell the scale without a solution. Despite setup-saying it was successful I get the Wrench icon and X in top right with nothing more than weight reading. Die smarte Index-Waage von Garmin ist die Ergänzung zum Training und den GPS-Sportuhren, kann aber auch separat genutzt werden. If that platform is Garmin Connect, and if you want those advanced metrics – then the Index Scale is solid and generally works well. The product has to work in the real world. If anyone out there has a solution, please let me know. Are we supposed to accept this? I guess I will have to stick with my TANITA BC1000, they are trusted, having tested them to be within fractions of specialised scales. Ignore your daily weight but pay attention to your 7 day average. I tried to add my husband and it deleted me. If it were the case that they had a boatload of work to do to enable this then fine but that’s not the case. For bone mass I think that over time it would show if I’m maintaining, gaining, or losing bone mass as I age (And improve my fitness). When I weigh someone else 20lb lighter, it decides that person is me, and associates it with me. Best wishes, Scott. However, the glossy black finish looks great when clean. I also just put together my complete ‘Gear I Use’ equipment list, from swim to bike to run and everything in between (plus a few extra things). I’m having EXACTLY the same issue. This seems to fix the problem. I’m also on the bandwagon of at least trying to get support. Use it for trending only. Please review our terms of service to complete your newsletter subscription. Interesting to hear that other have the same problem. Weigh-ins now carry a time stamp, but there is no way to see anything other than the last recorded measurement in either the Mobile Connect app or on the web. Cookie Settings | Any good scales out there you’d recommend? Any ideas? Great post. Maybe that’s the issue. It should be computer compatible out of the box without a fancy adapter. They already have the platform (Garmin Connect Auto Sync) setup to do exactly this. In fact, one of my routers at the studio wasn’t working with the latest Withings scale, whereas my home ones work just fine. Bone Mass 15.7 lbs, Brad, It’s been popular amongst TrainerRoad users: link to forum.trainerroad.com. ?” symbol but it doesn’t consistently. Which is both a cop-out and a LIE. The instructions are ABOMINABLE regarding adding another person. Not Funny at all. I have set it up on my iphone Garmin app and now my husband trying to add to his. It really does not sync to MyFitnessPal, and this has apparently been an issue for over a year. Hmmm. I bought these scales on the back of all my other products are gramin. as Ray describe in his other post “A Weighty Decision: Deciding on a WiFi Weight Scale”(link to dcrainmaker.com) it only syncs weight via the workaround withings -> fitnesspal -> garmin, the previous post is also a good reado for the whole topic! Have had years of intermittent wifi/connection issues. None of the advanced metrics are going to help you achieve your goals because they aren’t accurate enough. I think this product was an experiment, a failed experiment, made by Garmin with customer’s money. However, for me they are most important to see how they change over time as I work to lose weight and improve my cardio fitness and strength. I changed over from the Aria to the Index in January – at the moment I am not amused at all! Why would someone obsess about weighing more in the evening compared to the morning is beyond me. I bought an Apple pen the other day took it out of the box plugged it into my iPad and the set-up was complete. Looking for the equipment I use day to day? In general there is a 0.2k difference between the garmin and withings scales. Now – I just ride, but it would be very nice if I could drop at least 20 pounds and get under 200 – I know this would greatly improve my cycling experience – and really… that’s what this is all about right? I’m generally on the bandwagon of numbers. The idea of a wifi scale integration is fantastic and something I desire. I am returning this second set for a refund. My body fat is about 15% and the scale gave me 9% or less. According to Garmin the scale only moves data around via wifi and uses bluetooth for set up only (why not bluetooth too if it is already on the scale). It’s paired and liked to my wifi, but I can not see it on my app. You may unsubscribe from these newsletters at any time. Garmin Index Smart Scale measures Weight, Body Mass Index (BMI), Body Fat, Water Percentage, Muscle Mass and Bone Mass. Well it’s not just that it doesn’t sync – as Kien suspected you don’t get those fields shown if you don’t connect a Garmin scale to your account, nor can you enter those fields manually (which is really dumb). I haven’t seen a pattern as to when or why this should happen. Anyone know if the data transfer to MFP has gotten any better? Curious if the multi-point weight recording ever arrived or if it is still a single measurement per day? You'll support the site, and get ad-free DCR! However, my wife does does not have a GC account and will not be using the scale the same way I intend to use it. The Garmin Auto Sync service could easily just send the Weight.fit files to 3rd parties just like it sends activities. Kind of useless. When configuring the scale with my android phone the fist time the last user profile setting was “low med of high” activity. I just got these scales to replace my Withings ones which died. I can also confirm that values regarding water, fat and muscles isnt compareable between Tanita and Garmin.Only reason to stop using my Tanita is that it requires me to keep my old Forerunner 610 to actually automatically sync my Tanita scale with Garmin Connect. Sweated a ton, as you can imagine. We inquired with the Garmin API team about 3rd party sync support and they responded that there are no plans to allow synching Smart Scale data to any platform other than Garmin Connect. We have Wifi and Bluetooth setup for our Fenixes too. This is easily the worst Garmin device (of many) I’ve ever purchased and used. I’m in the market for wifi scales, and being a family who has multiple Garmin devices would like to keep the data in Garmin Connect. However, if you didn’t want to track that secondary weigh in you wouldn’t need to do anything, just let the scale deposit it into wifi/Garmin Connect land. For someone just aiming to lose weight and using a Vivosmart HR, it’s actually a pretty good compliment. link to forums.garmin.com. Ray. So there STILL isn’t really any way to get my weight into Training Peaks? I have adjusted my “activity class” from 8 down to 7 (as anything of 8 or higher is apparently considered to be an athlete which reduces the BF measurement, even though I exercise a that level according to the guidance provided by Garmin) and hopefully that will provide a fix, although I’m yet to find that out. Everything is pretty straightforward here. It needs quite a firm tap, and if you miss it, then you end up with your measurements being overwritten by the other user. Smart scales Garmin Index is intended for both professional athletes and for healthy lifestyle supporters. That’s implying that at some point the other scale metrics are imported and that’s never been the case. I was sent an ANT+ stick that also didn’t help. But even following the WiFi thread someone else posted, the last post there was nearly a month ago, and so it doesn’t seem too systematic (anymore so than other WiFi scales and the occasional router oddity). Whether or not one wants to accept it, the reality is that WiFi router setups vary significantly, and the tiniest of things can cause any other devices problems. I agree with you that it *should* default to the “? For example, on this, if I outlined the pros as ‘Just works’ (which it does for me), and left it as that, while listing a bunch of cons about issues with 3rd parties, no weigh-in, etc.., then people for whatever reason see that as a negative product, without reading whether or not it matters. Although my son gets mad at the scale when it shows he has went below 100 lbs again. I’ve literally bought dozens of Garmin fitness products dating back to the FR305 but without hesitation this was the worst experience and product I ever bought. The first one I got never worked right, recording, displaying and reporting only weight and BMI. WiFi issues are more than just an anomaly, just head over to the Garmin forums to see the pain people are having. Hi, Just wanted to let you know, that the connect app, will in fact show the weight form the smart scale, as a “snapshot” and not just buried way down in the menus. Unfortunately that’s not an option. The withings scale gives more reliable readings but love the look of the garmin better. For example, I weighed myself before and after a 3 hour ride in North Carolina summer heat/humidity with a heat index of close to 100 deg. I’ve just found out that Garmin Index Scale doesn’t measure visceral fat and metabolic age, which are important measures for me. Other scales at gyms I used are able to report a BF% under 7. Love the mix of tech and fitness. Want to compare the features of each product, down to the nitty-gritty? Try some different DNS server settings on your router like 1.1.1.1 or 8.8.8.8 etc. I use an old Garmin Edge 800 just for getting the Tanita BC 1000 recording in Garmin Connect. You said that from the end of last year the weight in your garmin devices is being updated Ehen syncing via the app. Paying this kind of $ should not require me to waste hours (and I already have on both sets). What are your least favorite countries/places? It happens every time and there is always same pattern – body weight up, water % down, body weight down, water % up. That said, I’m still not clear what the problem is you’re having, besides some sort of issue with connecting to your router. I had to google and did find this review and your question. FitTrack scale review: the home smart scale proven to provide accurate tracking of body composition metrics such as weight, BMI, body fat, and more. You can add up to 16 users on the Index Scale, where each person’s data is tied to a Garmin Connect account.

Supermarket Meal Kits, Lumber Mills Near Me, Warzone Gold Mask Operator Season 5, Pso2 Tweaker Uninstall, Ouray Fireworks 2020 New Year's, Vegan Shrimp Amazon, Michigan Collection Agency License Lookup, Gino's East Frozen Pizza Aldi,